THE PENNY LANE | Cheap Hotel in Hampton Bays | Book & Save

75 photos

The Penny Lane Hotel Hampton Bays Beds photo

The Penny Lane Hotel Hampton Bays Exterior photo

Book through our site

—up to 10% cheaper

than Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

16 Penny Lane - Full Hotel, Hampton Bays, New York, United States, 11946

Near Adventure Paddleboards & Kayaks

Great

8.9

8.6

/10

4.7

4.6

Loved by The Penny Lane Hotel guests

Canal views
Comfortable beds
Attentive staff
Pet-friendly policy

"Room was clean and comfortable with a water view."

Michele from United States

read full review

"Awesome location next to the water. Loved the outdoor space"

Konstantinos from United States

read full review

"The outdoor seats on the inlet were very nice for sunset."

Emily M from United States

read full review

"The canal view is gorgeous and walking distance to many restaurants"

Heather Y from United States

read full review

"The beds are ridiculously comfy."

nmquattr from United States

read full review

Amenities & Services

The Penny Lane offers a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and free bicycle rental. Free private parking is available on site for all guests. The hotel provides private check-in/check-out and a safety deposit box.

Rooms

Rooms at The Penny Lane have a private bathroom with a bath and hairdryer. Each room includes a TV and air conditioning. Some rooms also feature a balcony and a seating area.

Location

The Penny Lane is situated in Hampton Bays, 26 km from Splish Splash water park. Montauk Point Lighthouse is 48 km away. Long Island MacArthur Airport is 56 km from the property.

Dining

A continental breakfast is available at The Penny Lane. The hotel offers BBQ facilities and a picnic area for outdoor dining. A vending machine provides snacks and drinks for guests.

Outdoor & Activities

Guests can use the free bicycle rental to explore the surrounding area. The seasonal outdoor swimming pool is open during warmer months. The property also has a garden and outdoor furniture for relaxation.

Highlights

Amenities: Free bicycle rental and seasonal outdoor pool

Rooms: Private bathroom with bath, some with balcony

Location: 26 km from Splish Splash, 48 km from Montauk Point Lighthouse

Dining: Continental breakfast

Pet Policy: Pet-friendly hotel

Outdoor: BBQ facilities and picnic area

“The Penny Lane in Hampton Bays feels like a well-kept secret, nestled along the tranquil inlet where cottages exude an undeniable charm. Its proximity to Dune Road puts you right in the heart of town, yet the property itself cultivates an atmosphere of peaceful retreat, especially evident in the beautifully appointed outdoor spaces overlooking the water. The attention to detail in the accommodations, from crisp linens to functional amenities, creates a sense of comfortable independence for any visitor.”

Olivia SmithEditor-in-Chief at Cheaphotels

View all

Select your room type

The hotel provides a selection of rooms—doubles, family rooms, and suites—with perks like free cancellation, breakfast options, and great value deals

Queen

2 persons

195 sq. feet

1 Double bed

Bathtub

Air conditioning

room details

King

2 persons

250 sq. feet

1 King-size bed

Bathtub

Air conditioning

room details

Main House Queen

2 persons

205 sq. feet

1 Double bed

Bathtub

Air conditioning

room details

Main House King

2 persons

280 sq. feet

1 King-size bed

Bathtub

Air conditioning

room details

Click button to see more rooms

Show all rooms

Show all roomsLess

Room rates & availability calendar

See the best prices and book your dates today!

Amenities & services

Real traveler stories and honest reviews—no glossy ads, just authentic feedback to guide your booking

Facilities: Great

8.5/10Review score

General

No smoking on site
Parking
Pets allowed
Smoke detectors
Fire extinguishers

Spa & Leisure

Seasonal outdoor pool

Room features

Free Wi-Fi in rooms
Air conditioning
Heating
Sitting area
Patio
Garden furniture
Tea and coffee facilities

The Penny Lane Hotel Location

16 Penny Lane - Full Hotel, Hampton Bays, New York, United States, 11946

Map view

16 Penny Lane - Full Hotel, Hampton Bays, New York, United States, 11946

City landmarks

Landmark

Adventure Paddleboards & Kayaks

2300 ft

Beach

Ponquogue Beach

1.4 mi

Landmark

Cor-J Seafood Corporation

4900 ft

Church

Saint Rosalie's Church

1.8 mi

Beach

Tiana Beach

1.7 mi

Landmark

Good Ground Park

1.8 mi

Landmark

Good Ground Antique Center

1.8 mi

Beach

Charles Altenkirch County Park

1.8 mi

Landmark

Antiques By James Maguire

1.8 mi

Landmark

Shinnecock East County Park

2.2 mi

Landmark

Wild By Nature

2.3 mi

Park

Meschutt Beach County Park

2.8 mi

Landmark

Shinnecock Bay

2.4 mi

Landmark

Shinnecock Canal

2.5 mi

Landmark

Red Creek Skate Park

2.6 mi

Landmark

Sears Bellows County Park

3.0 mi

Beach

Hot Dog Beach

3.0 mi

Nearby

Penny Pond

1700 ft

Restaurants

Beach Bar

2400 ft

58 Foster Ave

78 Foster Restaurant & Bar

3600 ft

78 Foster Ave

Tully's

3600 ft

Dune Rd

Explore Hampton Bays

Adventure Paddleboards & Kayaks

10 minutes' walk

Water sports hub offering rentals for paddle boarding and kayaking. Perfect for a day of adventure on the water.

Ponquogue Beach

5 minutes' drive

Beautiful sandy beach with lifeguards, ideal for sunbathing and swimming. Stunning sunsets make it a must-visit!

Penny Pond

6 minutes' walk

Serene pond area with trails, perfect for nature walks and birdwatching. Great spot for a leisurely afternoon.

Surfing Lessons

5 minutes' drive

Thrill-seekers can try surfing lessons at nearby beaches. Rentals and instruction available for all skill levels.

Yoga by the Beach

5 minutes' drive

Relaxing outdoor yoga sessions available at the beach. Classes welcome beginners and advanced alike, often run at sunrise.

Beach Bar

9 minutes' walk

Casual dining with beach views. Enjoy fresh seafood and signature cocktails in a laid-back atmosphere.

78 Foster Restaurant & Bar

13 minutes' walk

Vibrant spot for American cuisine with a twist. Reservations recommended for weekend dining.

Live Music at The Bay

5 minutes' drive

Charming venue hosting weekly live music events. Perfect for enjoying local talent in a cozy atmosphere.

Shinnecock Canal

10 minutes' drive

Picturesque area for a family stroll. Observing boats and wildlife creates a tranquil experience.

Getting around town

City Centre

Hampton Bays11 min · 4.3 mi

Airports

Long Island MacArthur (ISP)86 min · 35.3 mi

Republic (FRG)128 min · 52.9 mi

Train

Southampton17 min · 6.8 mi

Looking for early-bird discounts?

Get special discounted rates today!

Check Rates

Property information and rules

Check-in

from 16:00-19:00

Check-out

until 11 am

Guest Parking

Private parking is possible on site for free.

Internet

Wireless internet is available in the hotel rooms for free.

Pets

Pets are allowed on request.

Number of rooms:

Former name

Drake Motor Inn

Reviews and Ratings

What past guests shared about their stay

Review score

Based on 44 verified reviews

9.1/10

Perfect

87%

Recommend

Cleanliness

8.7/10

Comfort

8.9/10

Facilities

8.5/10

Free Wi-Fi

7.5/10

Location

9.3/10

Staff

8.2/10

Value for money

8.2/10

Pros

Water view

Comfortable bed

Responsive hospitality

Cons

Noisy air conditioner

Small room size

Damp room conditions

No reviews yet on our siteUnfortunately, our guests have not yet left any reviews for this hotel, but you can read reviews from Booking.com.

Open reviews

FAQs

About The Penny Lane

What is the distance from The Penny Lane to Long Island MacArthur Airport?

The hotel is located 56 km from Long Island MacArthur Airport.

Which popular attractions are close to The Penny Lane?

Nearby attractions include Montauk Point Lighthouse (48 km), Agawam Park (15 km), and Splish Splash (26 km).

Is parking available at The Penny Lane?

The hotel offers free private parking on-site.

What amenities are available in the rooms at The Penny Lane?

Rooms feature air conditioning, a flat-screen TV, a coffee machine, and a private bathroom with complimentary toiletries.

What breakfast options does The Penny Lane offer?

A continental breakfast is available at the hotel.

Does The Penny Lane have a pool?

Guests can enjoy a seasonal outdoor swimming pool.

What are the check-in and check-out times at The Penny Lane?

Check-in is from 14:00 and check-out is by 11:30.

Are there any nearby restaurants to The Penny Lane?

Nearby restaurants include Tully's Seafood Market & Snack Shack, Tully's, 78 Foster Restaurant & Bar, and The Inn Spot on the Bay, all located within 1 km.

What recreational activities are available at The Penny Lane?

The hotel offers bicycle rentals and access to a nearby beach.